Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Table of Contents

Introduction: Why You’ll Love This Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Amish chicken salad is simple, hearty, and packed with flavor. It’s made with wholesome ingredients and a creamy, tangy dressing that’s hard to resist. Whether you serve it cold or warm, this salad brings comfort and tradition to your table. Perfect for picnics, sandwiches, or an easy lunch. Keep reading to learn how to make this classic dish at home — it’s easier than you think!

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Ingredients for Authentic Amish Chicken Salad

The beauty of Amish chicken salad lies in its simplicity. It uses everyday ingredients that come together to create a rich and satisfying flavor. Here’s what you typically need:

Basic Ingredients:

  • Cooked chicken: Traditionally shredded or chopped, rotisserie or poached chicken works well. White meat is commonly used, but dark meat adds extra flavor.
  • Mayonnaise: Gives the salad its creamy texture. Use full-fat for richness or a lighter version if preferred.
  • Hard-boiled eggs: Chopped eggs add protein and a subtle flavor that blends well with the creamy base.
  • Celery: Adds crunch and freshness. Dice it finely for even texture.
  • Sweet pickle relish: A classic Amish touch that brings a sweet and tangy flavor.
  • Yellow mustard: A small amount adds color and a tangy bite.
  • Salt and black pepper: Simple seasonings to enhance the natural flavors.

Optional Add-Ins:

  • Chopped onions: For a sharper flavor (red or sweet onions are best).
  • Sugar: Just a pinch can balance out the tanginess if using a lot of mustard or vinegar.
  • Apple cider vinegar: Adds a mild tang and keeps the flavor light.
  • Paprika: For color and a subtle smokiness.
  • Chopped parsley: For a fresh, herby finish.

Ingredient Scaling:

If you’re making this salad for a larger crowd or prepping ahead:

  • 1x for small servings (2–3 people)
  • 2x for family-sized batches
  • 3x for gatherings or meal prep

Most ingredients can be easily doubled or tripled without affecting the flavor balance.

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Recommended Equipment

You don’t need any fancy tools to make Amish chicken salad, which makes it even more appealing for home cooks. Here’s a list of basic kitchen equipment that will help you prep and mix the salad efficiently:

Large Mixing Bowl

A deep mixing bowl gives you enough space to combine all ingredients without spilling. Choose a bowl with a non-slip base for better grip while mixing.

Cutting Board and Sharp Knife

You’ll need a sturdy cutting board and a sharp knife to chop or shred the chicken, dice celery, and slice eggs or onions. A separate board for meats and vegetables is a good idea for food safety.

Measuring Cups and Spoons

Accurate measuring ensures the perfect balance of flavors. Use these to measure mayonnaise, mustard, relish, and seasonings.

Mixing Spoon or Silicone Spatula

A spoon or spatula helps mix the salad gently without breaking down the texture of the chicken or eggs too much. A rubber spatula is also great for scraping down the bowl.

Fork or Potato Masher (Optional)

Some prefer a slightly mashed consistency in Amish chicken salad. A fork or masher can help break down eggs or soften chicken pieces if desired.

Airtight Storage Container

To keep the salad fresh, especially if making ahead, store it in a lidded airtight container. It helps lock in flavor and prevents it from drying out in the fridge.

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

How to Make Amish Chicken Salad (Step-by-Step Instructions)

Making Amish chicken salad is quick and easy. Follow these step-by-step instructions to prepare a creamy, flavorful dish that’s perfect for any occasion.

Step 1: Cook and Shred the Chicken

Use 2 to 3 cups of cooked chicken (poached, roasted, or rotisserie). Shred or chop the chicken into bite-sized pieces. Let it cool completely before mixing to avoid melting the mayo.

  • Tip: For added flavor, cook the chicken in broth or season it with salt and pepper before poaching.

Step 2: Prepare the Other Ingredients

Hard-boil 2 large eggs, then peel and chop them once cooled. Dice 1–2 stalks of celery finely for crunch.

Measure out your other ingredients:

  • ½ cup mayonnaise
  • 1–2 tablespoons sweet pickle relish
  • 1 teaspoon yellow mustard
  • Salt and black pepper to taste

Step 3: Combine in a Mixing Bowl

In a large bowl, add the shredded chicken, chopped eggs, and celery. Stir in the mayonnaise, relish, and mustard. Mix gently until everything is evenly coated and combined.

  • Optional Add-ins: A pinch of sugar, a splash of apple cider vinegar, or a sprinkle of paprika can be added here based on your flavor preference.

Step 4: Chill Before Serving

Cover the bowl and refrigerate the salad for at least 30 minutes. This resting time allows the flavors to meld and improves texture.

Step 5: Taste and Adjust

After chilling, give it a quick stir and taste. Adjust seasoning if needed a little more salt, pepper, or mustard can bring the flavors alive.

Hot Amish Chicken Salad Variation (Optional)

Want to try a baked version?

Mix in shredded cheese and crushed crackers on top. Bake in a casserole dish at 350°F (175°C) for 20–25 minutes, or until bubbly and golden.

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Flavor Boosters & Seasoning Tips

While Amish chicken salad is known for its simple, comforting taste, a few smart seasoning choices can take it from good to unforgettable. Here are some easy ways to enhance flavor without losing its traditional charm:

Salt and Pepper The Basics

Always start with a pinch of salt and a dash of black pepper. Adjust to taste after mixing and chilling the salad. Don’t overdo it this salad is meant to be mild and comforting.

Mustard Tangy Depth

Yellow mustard is most commonly used in Amish chicken salad for its mellow tang. For more bite, try a small amount of Dijon or spicy brown mustard (start with ½ teaspoon).

Sweet Pickle Relish Classic Amish Flavor

Adds sweetness, moisture, and a subtle zing. If you prefer a less sweet version, use dill relish instead.

Sugar Optional Sweetness

A tiny pinch (¼ to ½ teaspoon) of sugar can round out the flavors, especially if using more vinegar or mustard. Many Amish-style recipes include a hint of sweetness for balance.

Apple Cider Vinegar A Bright Touch

Just ½ teaspoon can lift the overall flavor and cut through richness. Add gradually and taste after mixing.

Celery Seed Old-Fashioned Flavor

A traditional spice in many Amish salads. Adds a peppery, earthy note great in small amounts (¼ teaspoon).

Paprika For Color and Mild Warmth

Sprinkle a little on top before serving for visual appeal and a gentle smoky flavor. Smoked paprika can add more depth if you want a bolder flavor.

Fresh Herbs Optional But Refreshing

Chopped parsley or dill can add a fresh, green lift. Use sparingly to keep the focus on the core ingredients.

Onion For a Sharp Kick

If you want extra bite, add 1–2 tablespoons of finely chopped red onion or green onion. Use sparingly so it doesn’t overpower the delicate flavors.

Tips for Best Flavor:

  • Chill before serving: gives the flavors time to blend.
  • Taste test after chilling: cold temps can dull flavors, so adjust seasoning just before serving.
  • Balance is key: Amish chicken salad should be creamy, slightly tangy, and lightly sweet—not overly spiced.
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Easy Recipe Variations

One of the best things about Amish chicken salad is how easily you can adapt it to suit your tastes or dietary needs. Whether you’re aiming for a lighter version, a more protein-rich salad, or just want to try something new, here are some popular and delicious variations:

Healthier Amish Chicken Salad

Use Greek yogurt instead of all or part of the mayonnaise for a lighter, protein-packed base. Add more veggies like shredded carrots, chopped cucumber, or diced bell pepper for crunch and color. Reduce the sugar or omit it entirely for a less sweet version.

Amish Chicken Salad with Grapes and Nuts

Add halved red or green grapes (about ½ cup) for a fresh burst of sweetness. Include chopped pecans or walnuts (¼ cup) for a rich, nutty crunch. This variation is popular at potlucks and gatherings because of its sweet-savory combo.

Egg-Free Version

Simply leave out the hard-boiled eggs if you have an allergy or prefer a smoother texture. Compensate with a little extra chicken or celery for body.

Amish Chicken Salad with Dill Pickles

Substitute sweet pickle relish with diced dill pickles for a tangier flavor. Add a teaspoon of fresh or dried dill to boost the herbal notes.

Spicy Amish Chicken Salad

Mix in a few dashes of hot sauce or cayenne pepper for a mild kick. Dice in some jalapeños for a bolder, spicy twist.

Amish-Style Chicken Salad Wraps

Use the classic salad as a filling for lettuce wraps, tortilla wraps, or pita pockets. Add shredded lettuce or sliced tomatoes to make it more refreshing and filling.

Hot Amish Chicken Salad Casserole

Mix the salad with shredded cheese, cooked pasta, and crushed buttery crackers on top. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 20–25 minutes until golden and bubbly. Great for a warm comfort-food-style dinner.

Amish Chicken Salad Sliders

Serve the salad on small buns or dinner rolls for an easy appetizer or party snack. Add a thin slice of cheese or a pickle slice for extra flavor.

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Serving Suggestions

Amish chicken salad is incredibly versatile and can be enjoyed in many different ways. Whether you’re planning a quick lunch, a light dinner, or a party tray, this salad fits right in. Here are some of the best ways to serve it:

Classic Sandwiches

Serve on sandwich bread, croissants, or hoagie rolls. Add lettuce, tomato, or sliced cheese for extra flavor and texture. Great for picnics, school lunches, or casual dinners.

Lettuce Wraps or Salad Bowls

For a low-carb option, spoon the salad into romaine or butter lettuce leaves. Or serve a scoop of chicken salad over a bed of mixed greens with sliced cucumbers and tomatoes. Drizzle with a little vinegar or lemon juice to freshen it up.

Crackers or Pita Chips

Serve as a dip or spread with crackers or pita chips. Ideal for a snack platter, party appetizer, or light meal. Add a small spoon to the serving bowl for easy scooping.

Stuffed Tomatoes or Avocados

Hollow out ripe tomatoes or avocado halves and fill with a scoop of chicken salad. This makes for a beautiful and refreshing summer lunch.

Amish Chicken Salad Wraps

Roll it in a soft flour tortilla with spinach, cheese, or shredded carrots. Slice into pinwheels for a quick lunchbox idea or finger food.

Open-Faced Melts

Spread chicken salad on slices of bread, top with shredded cheese, and broil for 3–4 minutes. This creates a warm, gooey, and slightly crispy version—perfect for a cozy meal.

Amish Chicken Salad Sliders

Spoon salad onto mini slider buns, add a pickle slice or cheese, and secure with toothpicks. Serve as game-day snacks, brunch bites, or party finger foods.

Paired with Sides

Great alongside potato salad, coleslaw, pasta salad, or even soup. Serve with sweet tea, lemonade, or iced coffee for a full Amish-style lunch experience.

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Storage and Leftovers

Proper storage is key to keeping your Amish chicken salad fresh, flavorful, and safe to eat. Whether you’re meal prepping or saving leftovers, follow these simple tips to maintain its quality.

How to Store Amish Chicken Salad

  • Use an airtight container: Transfer the chicken salad to a sealed, lidded container to prevent it from drying out or absorbing fridge odors.
  • Refrigerate promptly: Always refrigerate the salad within 1–2 hours of making it, especially if it has been sitting at room temperature.
  • Ideal storage temperature: Keep it chilled at or below 40°F (4°C).

How Long Does It Last?

Fresh Amish chicken salad will keep for 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. After that, the texture may break down and the flavor may fade, so it’s best enjoyed within that time frame.

Can You Freeze Amish Chicken Salad?

Freezing is not recommended for chicken salad made with mayonnaise. The mayo tends to separate and become watery once thawed, affecting both the texture and taste.

If you must freeze:

Freeze only the cooked chicken portion without the mayo and other mix-ins. Thaw in the refrigerator and mix in the dressing fresh before serving.

How to Refresh Leftover Chicken Salad

Stir well before serving to redistribute moisture and flavors. If it looks dry, add a spoonful of mayo or a splash of vinegar or lemon juice to freshen it up. Taste and adjust seasoning as needed after storing.

Safety Tips

Discard if left out at room temperature for more than 2 hours (or 1 hour on hot days). Don’t reuse utensils that have touched other foods or your mouth when serving from the container.

  • Smell test: If it smells sour, off, or has an unusual color, it’s best to throw it away.
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Nutrition Information

Understanding the nutritional profile of Amish chicken salad can help you enjoy it mindfully—whether you’re watching calories, carbs, or just looking for a balanced meal. While exact values can vary based on the specific ingredients and portion sizes, here’s a general breakdown based on a 1-cup serving of classic Amish chicken salad made with mayonnaise, eggs, and relish.

Estimated Nutrition per 1 Cup Serving:

  • Calories: 350–400 kcal
  • Protein: 20–25 grams
  • Fat: 25–30 grams
  • Carbohydrates: 5–10 grams
  • Fiber: 0–1 gram
  • Sugar: 2–4 grams
  • Cholesterol: 120–160 mg
  • Sodium: 400–600 mg

Nutritional Highlights:

  • High in protein: Thanks to the chicken and eggs, this salad is a great source of protein, which helps keep you full.
  • Low in carbs: Ideal for low-carb and keto-friendly diets, especially when served without bread or crackers.
  • High in fat and cholesterol: Mainly from mayonnaise and eggs. Consider using light mayo or Greek yogurt for a healthier version.
  • Moderate sodium content: Relish and mustard can raise the sodium level. If you’re watching salt intake, choose low-sodium ingredients.

Tips for a Healthier Version:

Swap mayo with Greek yogurt (full or low-fat) for a lighter dressing with more protein and less fat. Use olive oil mayo for healthier fats. Add fresh veggies like bell peppers, cucumber, or shredded carrots to increase fiber and nutrients. Control portion sizes when serving with bread or crackers, as those can add calories and carbs quickly.

Final Notes & Helpful Tips

Making Amish chicken salad is simple, but a few thoughtful touches can elevate it from ordinary to outstanding. Whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned cook, these final tips and notes will help you get the best results every time.

Use High-Quality Chicken

The flavor of your salad depends heavily on the chicken you use. Rotisserie chicken adds richness and convenience. Poached or baked chicken breasts are leaner and easier to season from scratch. Dark meat (like thighs) adds more flavor and moisture, if preferred.

Let It Chill Before Serving

Allow at least 30 minutes in the fridge before serving. Chilling helps the flavors meld and improves texture. Cold chicken salad also tastes fresher and is more refreshing.

Don’t Overmix

Gently fold the ingredients together to avoid a mushy texture. Overmixing can break down the chicken and eggs too much.

Taste and Adjust Seasoning Last

Cold temperatures dull flavor, so always taste and adjust salt, pepper, mustard, or relish after chilling. Add fresh herbs or a squeeze of lemon juice if it tastes too heavy.

Make It Your Own

Amish recipes vary from family to family. Don’t be afraid to tweak the recipe based on your preferences. Try different mustards, sweeteners (like honey or maple syrup), or relish types to find your favorite flavor profile.

Prep in Advance for Better Flavor

Amish chicken salad is a great make-ahead dish. It often tastes better the next day as the ingredients have more time to blend.

Serving Size Tip

For sandwiches, plan on ½ to ¾ cup per person. For party trays or light sides, ¼ to ½ cup is often enough.

Pair with Fresh and Crunchy Sides

Balance the creamy texture with sides like fresh fruit, pickles, coleslaw, or sliced cucumbers.

Conclusion

In summary, Amish chicken salad is a simple yet satisfying recipe that brings together tradition, comfort, and great taste. With easy-to-find ingredients and plenty of room for personalization, it’s a dish you can enjoy in many ways—from classic sandwiches to low-carb wraps. Whether you’re making it for a family lunch, a picnic, or meal prep, this wholesome salad is sure to become a favorite. Try it once, and you’ll keep coming back to its timeless flavor.

FAQS

One of the best secret ingredients in chicken salad is a splash of pickle juice or a bit of Dijon mustard. These add a subtle tanginess that brightens the flavors. Other popular secret ingredients include chopped apples, fresh herbs (like dill or tarragon), or a pinch of curry powder for extra depth.
A simple four-ingredient chicken salad typically includes:Cooked chicken (shredded or chopped)MayonnaiseCelery (for crunch)Salt and pepper (counted together as seasoning) Optional swaps might include grapes instead of celery or Greek yogurt in place of mayo.
Amish chicken usually refers to birds raised by Amish farmers, often in more traditional, small-scale, free-range environments without antibiotics or hormones. This can result in richer flavor and better texture compared to mass-produced regular chicken, which may be factory-farmed and processed on a larger scale.
Common ingredients in chicken salad include:Cooked chicken (chopped or shredded)Mayonnaise or Greek yogurtCelery, onion, or scallionsGrapes, cranberries, or apples (optional)Nuts like almonds or pecans (optional)Herbs like dill, parsley, or tarragonSalt, pepper, and lemon juice for flavor
To boost the flavor of chicken salad:Use fresh herbs like dill, basil, or parsleyAdd a touch of acid lemon juice or vinegarInclude crunchy elements like nuts or celeryMix in sweet and savory balance grapes, cranberries, or picklesUse well-seasoned chicken and let it chill for a few hours to blend flavors
Avoid these common mistakes:Overdressing with too much mayo (makes it soggy)Using unseasoned or bland chicken (flavor starts with the meat)Skipping texture (always add something crunchy)Serving it warm (it should be chilled for best flavor)Leaving it out too long (always refrigerate to prevent spoilage)
Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Amish Chicken Salad Recipe

Discover the authentic Amish chicken salad recipe made with simple, wholesome ingredients. Perfect for sandwiches, picnics, or a hearty lunch at home!
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Servings: 4
Course: Appetizer, Main Course, Salad
Cuisine: American

Ingredients
  

  • 2 cups diced cooked chicken
  • ½ cup mayo
  • ¼ teaspoon teaspoon black pepper
  • ½ teaspoon salt or to taste
  • 2 teaspoons prepared mustard
  • 3 tablespoons chopped onions opt
  • ½ cup shredded cheese opt
  • ½ cup pickle relish opt
  • dash liquid smoke opt

Method
 

  1. Chop or dice chicken.
  2. In a medium bowl, mix all together.
  3. Serve on a slice of bread or tortilla wrap.
  4. If desired, top with lettuce, tomato slices, or cheese

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating